February 4, 2021

Why Some Law School Applicants Underperform Their Numbers

Why Some Law School Applicants Underperform Their NumbersPodcast Banner Image
Why Some Law School Applicants Underperform Their NumbersPodcast Banner Image

In this podcast, Mike Spivey discusses factors that lead to some applicants "underperforming" their numbers. You can listen to this podcast below, or on SoundCloud  or Apple Podcasts.

Introduction

  • 0:46 - Will more people underperform this cycle? (2020-2021)
  • 1:41 - Defining "Underperform"

Factors that can lead to underperforming your numbers

  • 4:44 - Character & Fitness Issues (but maybe not in the way you think)
  • 6:44 - Yield Protection
  • 8:17 - Overcommunicating
  • 10:40 - Sloppiness

Answering Questions from Reddit

  • 13:05 - "Is it the essay or lack of an added essay (DS) that throws off an entire application?"
  • 14:44 - "Is having a non legal job in Biglaw going in a boost as schools will see you connections that may help boost the schools standing?"
  • 15:26 - "How disadvantaged are KJDs in the admissions process?"
  • 16:59 - "Do GRE applicants more often underperform their numbers? With the high LSAT saturation, will this negatively affect GRE applicants?"
  • 17:54 - "Considering how some services quantify the 'URM Boost' in applications (7Sage predictor and LSData URM LSAT/GPA differential, for example), what specifically causes URMs to underperform their stats?"
  • 19:41 - "I’ve been rejected by UMich with a 3.mid and 17high, does this count as underperforming my numbers? If so, is this indicative of how the rest of my cycle with the T14 will go?"
  • 20:02 - "Any data / longitudinal studies on engineers?"
  • 20:42 - "I’m sure this will vary by schools, but in your experience as someone who made decisions on files, if a candidate is at/above both of a school’s target medians AND has demonstrated genuine interest, how much can those two factors carry them if the rest of the app is average? Will the answer to this question be different this year because of the availability of good stats?"
  • 21:28 - "Would you say if there are multiple LSAT scores without a consistent increase in score (i.e. there was a score drop before the ultimate high score) then that person is likely to underperform? Especially asking for T6/T14? Would your answer change if the final score was a 175+?"

Conclusion

  • 23:48 - Takeaways & Predictions for the Rest of the Cycle
Podcast Transcript
Featuring

Founder and CEO

Mike Spivey is one of the world's foremost legal and higher education experts.

Latest Podcasts

Podcast CoverPodcast Cover
November 13, 2026
2026–27 Cycle Data Update with Dave Killoran

In this episode of Status Check with Spivey, Mike Spivey is joined by Dave Killoran to discuss the latest data from the 2026–27 law school admissions cycle. They examine early applicant trends, rising LSAT scores, and what the numbers could mean for applicants as the cycle progresses.

Mike and Dave discuss why applicant numbers are currently up around 10% and why that increase may decline as the cycle continues (0:08), how rising numbers of high LSAT scores could affect admissions competitiveness (4:27), and why perfect 180 scores have increased by more than 47% (9:31). They also explore how LSAT scoring scales and potential changes to the exam may be contributing to these trends.

Additional topics include LSAT test-taker numbers for the remainder of the year (13:23), why the 2026–27 cycle could be one of the slowest on record (15:05), and why applicants may wait several months for decisions without that necessarily being a bad sign (16:54).

Podcast CoverPodcast Cover
November 3, 2026
Do Resume Gaps Hurt You?

Do resume gaps hurt your law school admissions chances? Is the so-called "KJD tax" real? And how much do GPA and LSAT medians actually matter?

In this episode of Status Check with Spivey, Mike Spivey and Spivey Consulting President Anna Hicks-Jaco answer questions submitted by the Reddit law school admissions community.

They discuss employment gaps, high-turnover jobs, low undergraduate GPAs, and how admissions committees evaluate applicants who have overcome significant adversity. They also explore the value of work experience, whether graduate GPAs can strengthen an application, and how schools set target LSAT medians.

Mike and Anna also share their perspectives on the GRE versus the LSAT, the growing acceptance of JD-Next, and why applicants should be cautious about misleading admissions advice online.

Additional resources and notes:

  • Resume gaps: For additional insights, listen to our recent conversation with UVA Law Dean of Admissions Natalie Blazer.
  • 2026–2027 admissions cycle data: The first cycle data is now available! We'll have a separate podcast analyzing the numbers soon.
  • Law school medians: Explore our law school admissions median tracker to see how schools' LSAT and GPA medians have changed.
  • GRE versus LSAT: Although reporting rules have changed, individual law schools may still consider both scores when evaluating applicants. Be sure to review the policies of the specific schools you're interested in.
  • JD-Next: Learn more in our previous episode featuring Craig Boise and Daniel Rodriguez.

Follow us on Instagram and TikTok @SpiveyConsulting for more law school admissions insights, updates, and resources.

Podcast CoverPodcast Cover
October 20, 2026
Dean Z on 5 Famous First Lines from Literature as Personal Statement Openings

What makes a great law school personal statement opening sentence? In this episode of Status Check with Spivey, Mike Spivey is joined by Sarah Zearfoss (Dean Z), Senior Assistant Dean at the University of Michigan Law School and former Dean of Admissions, to evaluate five famous opening lines from literature and discuss how they would work as personal statement introductions.

They explore the importance of authenticity and avoiding overly dramatic writing (1:41), finding the balance between creativity and trying too hard (2:16), writing about family and making bold claims (3:47), and keeping the focus on your own story (5:22). They also discuss using personal growth and reflection to create compelling openings (6:35) and navigating political or controversial topics in law school applications (7:13).

Through their reactions and occasional disagreements, Mike and Dean Z offer insights into what makes an opening sentence memorable- and what might make an admissions officer think twice.